Eye liner review: Physicians Formula custome eye enhancing eye linertrio Nude Collection

Hi Everyone,

I hope your having a wonderful week, today I will be reviewing the Physicians Formula eyeliner. Physicians formula is well known for mineral make up at drugstore prices. Physician's formula focus mostly of face products from powders, bronzers, some foundations and a few eye products. Today I will be reviewing the Physicians Formula customeye enhancing eyeliner trio in Nude.

front of the box

I have a very high standard when it comes to eyeliners, I love my Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on eyeliners. To give a brief background I have asian eyes and they are semi hooded typical of most Asians and I also have very oily eyelids so eyeshadows crease and disappear on my eyelids and eyeliners migrate down and give me raccoon eyes

the back of the box

what am I looking for in an eyeliner?
I want a very creamy, smooth eyeliner, when I use the eyeliner, it should just glide over my eyelids or waterline with out tugging.
I want a very pigmented eyeliner, I want a rich colored eyeliner that I don't need to build up to get any color.
I want an eyeliner that stays put but smudgeable. I don't want an eyeliner traveling down my eyes making me look like a raccoon by the end of the day.
I would like a wide selection of colors other than the basics which is  black, navy, dark brown and white. It's not a deal breaker but it's nice to have.
I have a high expectations when it comes to eyeliner it has to perform well

Physician's formula eye enhancing eyeliner trio in nude

Product claims:
Warm Nude Eyeliner Trio! The perfect set of earth tone eyeliners to create a Warm Nude look for ANY eye color!
Long-wearing, water-resistant and smudge-resistant formula for 24-Hour wear.
Hypoallergenic. Fragrance-free. Paraben-Free. Gluten Free. Dermatologist approved. Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Product experience:

You get 3 automatic eyeliners in set, I bought the nude eyes, so in this set it has a champagne, a pewter and a shimmery black. These are automatic eye liners, meaning you don't need to sharpen them you just twist the bottom and the eyeliner will come up it also comes with a sharpener at the bottom of the pencil.
The formula of the eyeliners can be hit or miss, out of the three the black eyeliner is the creamiest. The other two are much drier in texture and needs a few passes to get any color intensity.

dark brown, champagne, black

Pros:

• You get a set of 3 different colored eyeliner.
• Automatic pencil liner never need sharpening.
• Comes with a built in sharpener.
• Great for the water line because of the drier texture
• It's comfortable to wear
• Widely available at most drugstores, walmart and target
• Inexpensive even though Physicians formula is on the higher end of the drugstore brand.

Cons:

• The quality is hit or miss some of the eyeliner is too hard and dry, it will tug on your eyelids
• Some of colors can be deceiving especially the champagne color, it's more a light taupe than a champagne.
• Some of eyeliner doesn't have a lot of pigment so you will need to swipe the liner a few times to get the desired effect.

I'm on the fence about this particular product, like I said the quality isn't exceptional but it's not bad either. I got the most use is the black eyeliner just because it's the creamiest liner in the group.